Ask A Researcher

June 2019

“Giving rope and pulling it back”: Parental dilemmas to prevent adolescent substance use

Shweta Arpit Srivastava (formerly Shweta Sharma) is a doctoral candidate in the Department of Communication at North Dakota State University. Dr. Ann Burnett is a Professor of Communication and Director of Women and Gender Studies at North Dakota State University.
This article is based on the scholarly article: Sharma, Shweta, & Burnett, Ann (2016). “Giving rope and pulling it back": Nurturing and control strategies used by parents to prevent adolescent substance use. Journal of Communication, Speech & Theater Association of North Dakota, 28(2), 42-55.

The current opioid crisis in the US warrants adolescent substance use prevention more than ever before, especially because drugs, alcohol, and suicides are contributing to an alarming drop in US life expectancy for the second year in a row. In such a scenario, parenting adolescents becomes increasingly challenging because, on one hand, parents learn scary facts from the media and feel the urge to protect their children; on the other hand, they need to continue to show love and care for their children. It is certainly hard to balance discipline and love. When a parent sees bad behavior, he or she might become stricter, and when he or she sees good behavior, it might be okay to grant some freedom. One might argue that these strategies are a part of normal parenting practices. However, communication research informs us differently. Beth Le Poire, a family communication scholar theorized that such intermittent use of strict control and lenience is problematic because it is confusing and frustrating for the child. Furthermore, such intermittent practices may reinforce the behavior (in this case adolescent substance use) that we try to curb.

Le Poire’s (1995) Inconsistent Nurturing as Control (INC) theory originally explained intermittent use of love and care as control by romantic partners of substance abusive individuals. The theory suggests that partners of substance abusers go through three stages:

1. Pre-labeling: This stage exists before the addictive behavior is labeled problematic. For example, a person may drink alcohol regularly but may not be labeled as an addict. In this stage, partners use communication and behaviors that nurture the habit, such as talking about benefits of taking alcohol in moderation, or participating in wine tastings, etc. Comparable behaviors for parents trying to prevent adolescent substance use could be allowing a sip of wine to demystify the concept of alcohol or allowing for more time at a friend’s place if the parents know the friend. Le Poire labelled such behaviors as nurturing behaviors.

2. Post-labeling: This stage exists after a noteworthy incident occurs, such as getting a warning email from the employer, or getting a DUI ticket. After such an incident, the addictive behavior is labeled as problematic, and most partners in this stage tend to withhold love and care, and become more controlling. They use strategies such as hiding car keys, or taking control over money. In a parent-child relationship, some of these behaviors can be compared to cutting back on screen time, stricter curfew times, or restricting access to certain friends. Le Poire called such behaviors as control (withdrawal of nurturing) behaviors.

3. Post-frustration:This stage begins after all efforts to curb the substance-abusive behavior fail. At this stage the partners have experienced that nurturing did not help in pre-labeling stage and withdrawal of nurturing did not help in post-labeling stage. Also, when using nurturing, the partners are afraid that they might be too lenient and they may give way to substance abusive behavior; in using control they may fear the possibility of losing trust and hurting the relationship. Therefore, in post-frustration stage, they unintentionally encourage the addictive behavior through inconsistent manifestation of nurturing and control. This is similar to parental dilemma of granting freedom and choices. We argue that in a parent-child relationship this stage exists even before pre-labeling because parents try similar strategies for prevention.

Parents nurture perceived good behavior and try to control perceived bad behavior by using a variety of communication strategies. They use strategies of nurturing by promoting open discussions, monitoring behavior and activities in respectful ways, and presenting models of responsible behavior. They use controlling strategies by enforcing rules, forcing discussions, and reprimanding deviant behavior.

Based on the understanding of nurturing and control, we conducted a study (Sharma & Burnett, 2016) to explore how parents respond to the possibility of adolescent substance use and what they are doing to prevent its occurrence. The results confirmed our assumption that parents are aware of the ill-effects of adolescent substance use and use communication strategies to attempt to prevent it. Parents often find themselves dealing with the dilemma of balancing love and nurturing with vigilance and control. Hence, they use communication strategies in hopes of controlling the adolescent’s behavior, but parents’ choice of strategy depends on the behavior.  One mother described this as, “giving rope and pulling it back.” In this study, parents explained that they did not want to be too strict so as to upset the relationship with their adolescent, but at the same time, they also wanted to make sure that their adolescent stayed away from the harms of substance use.  Parents revealed that they extend privileges if they observe good behavior, and they make rules stricter and controls tighter if the children do not match the standards created in the household to keep check on substance use. Overall, parents give “a little bit of rope at a time.”

Our findings indicated that nurturing and controlling strategies create three paradoxes (Sharma & Burnett, 2016) when parents try to prevent adolescent substance use. First, both parents and adolescents have agency and control in the relationship. This is why parents sometimes cannot hold a discussion because young people tend to drift away or check out. For example, on some occasions, parents may be successful in enforcing curfew times, but they also relax curfew times when adolescents show good behavior. Second, parents feel obligated to sacrifice for their children while simultaneously dealing with issues of self-fulfillment. For example, a parent might consider not having more than one glass of wine in front of children, and they might hide the second glass. Third, there is a need to control the adolescent’s behavior but there is also the desire to maintain love in the relationship.  A father might stay up until his adolescent comes home from a late night event, spend enough time with him to make sure the adolescent is sober, but refrain from accusing the adolescent of drinking.

As explained through the findings of this study, parents try to prevent adolescent substance use through intermittent use of nurturing and control. This stage can be labeled as prevention stage. INC theory explains that outcomes (Prescott & Le Poire, 2002) in one stage impact the choice of strategies in the next stage. If the use of nurturing fails in pre-labeling stage. This leads to the use of excessive control in post-labeling stage. Similarly, when withholding nurturing fails in the post-labeling stage, it leads to frustration. As per INC theory, such inconsistent use of nurturing and control reinforces the behavior we try to restrict. Therefore, it is important to re-examine the age-old parental script of “giving rope and pulling it back,” and it is necessary to address more effectively the dilemmas parents face when it comes to preventing adolescent substance use. We recommend a closer examination of parent-child communication regarding prevention of adolescent substance use.

References

Le Poire, B. A. (1995). Inconsistent nurturing as control theory: Implications for communication-based research and treatment programs. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 23, 60-74. doi:10.1080/00909889509365414


Prescott, M. E., & Le Poire, B. A. (2002). Eating disorders and mother-daughter communication: A test of of inconsistent nurturing as control theory. The Journal of Family Communication, 2, 59-78. doi:10.1207/S15327698JFC0202_01


Sharma, S., & Burnett, A. (2016). “Giving rope and pulling it back": Nurturing and control strategies used by parents to prevent adolescent substance use. Journal of Communication, Speech & Theater Association of North Dakota, 28(2), 42-55.

 

Ask a researcher archive

Aastha Bhandari, Debarati Kole, Dr. Nancy Hodur. Mission Of Mercy: Giving hope through a asmile.
July 2022

Ina Cernusca.Households with children have been disproportionately affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, especially in the first year of the pandemic.
May 2022

Andy Wiese and Karen Olson. One Health System’s Approach to Improving Community Health. Understanding what the 2021 Community Health Needs Assessment Conducted by Sanford Health means for population health
April 2022

Mariel Lopez-Valentin and Grace Njau. North Dakota Title X, Family Planning Needs Assessment
January 2022

Nancy Hodur and Dean Bangsund. North Dakota Lignite Energy Industry Workforce
December 2021

Ina Cernusca. Vaccine Acceptance and Hesitancy in North Dakota
October 2021

Nancy Hodur and Karen Olson. Rural Communities Will Benefit from a New Cooperative in Walsh County
September 2021

Matt Schmidt and Grace Njau. COVID-19 Trends Among North Dakota Children, March 2020 – March 2021
August 2021

Kendra Erickson-Dockter and Ina Cernusca. COVID Hardship on North Dakota Households: New study on the impacts on North Dakota households that lost employment income during the pandemic
July 2021

Chelsey Hukriede and Kendra Erickson-Dockter. NEW! PRAMS Points – A Brief Infographic using North Dakota PRAMS Survey Data
May 2021

North Dakota Compass: A look inside the 2021 Compass Points
April 2021

Ina Cernusca: Households with children are disproportionately affected by the COVID-19 pandemic
March 2021

Ina Cernusca: Differences in COVID-19 Risk Factors at District Level
February 2021

Kendra Erickson-Dockter, Chelsey Hukriede, and Grace Njau: An Introduction to the North Dakota Study of Associated Risks of Stillbirth (SOARS)
October 2020

Karen Ehrens: North Dakota Families are Facing Food and Other Hardships in the Wake of COVID-19 Pandemic, and Helpers Respond
September 2020

Ina Cernusca: Taking the pulse of North Dakota households during the COVID-19 pandemic.
July 2020

Nancy Hodur:Challenges of Grocery Stores in Rural North Dakota
May 2020

North Dakota Compass:2020 Compass Points: Measuring progress. Inspiring action.
March 2020

Amy Tichy:Student Veterans in the College Classroom.
February 2020

North Dakota Compass:North Dakota Compass launches the 2020 State Legislative District Profiles
January 2020

Grace Njau, Nancy Hodur:&Chelsey Hukriede: Risk Behaviors among Women with a Recent Live Birth in North Dakota: Findings from the 2017 North Dakota Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS)
November 2019

Ina Cernusca:& Karen Olson: Behind the scenes – The story of the North Dakota State Legislative District Profiles
October 2019

Ina Cernusca: Key demographic trends in North Dakota.
August 2019

Karen Olson: The 30th edition of the Annie E. Casey Foundation’s KIDS COUNT® Data Book finds that 175,772 children will shape the future of a more diverse North Dakota.
July 2019

Shweta Arpit Srivastava & Dr. Ann Burnett: “Giving rope and pulling it back”: Parental dilemmas to prevent adolescent substance use
June 2019

Ina Cernusca: 2019 Compass Points: Setting direction for improving the quality of life in North Dakota
May 2019

Joshua Marineau and Onnolee Nordstrom: Learning from Fargo -- An Exploration of the Fargo-Moorhead Entrepreneurial Ecosystem
March 2019

Nancy Hodur: Improving Oral Health for Older Adults in North Dakota
November 2018

Rachelle Vettern: Engaging Volunteers across Generations
October 2018

Karen Olson: The 2018 KIDS COUNT® Data Book reveals strengths and challenges for children in North Dakota – and emphasizes that an inaccurate census in 2020 threatens to worsen existing challenges for North Dakota youth
July 2018

Lori Capouch: Is food access a concern in rural North Dakota?
May 2018

Deb Nelson: Williston Basin 2016: Employment, Population, and Housing Forecasts – An Overview
January 2018

Karen Olson: North Dakota among Top 10 States in Country for Child Well-Being
July 2017

Nancy Hodur: SEAL!North Dakota: A School Dental Sealant Program
June 2017

Grace Njau: A Brief Introduction to the North Dakota Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS)
April 2017

Ina Cernusca: North Dakota’s Women study: A brief overview
March 2017

Dean Bangsund: Effects of Fargo-Moorhead Area Diversion on Spring Planting for Producers
February 2017

Deb Nelson: Vision West: Leading, Educating, and Collaborating to Mobilize the 19 Western North Dakota Counties Towards Resilience and Prosperity
December 2016

Nancy Hodur: North Dakota Statewide Housing Needs Assessment: A Brief Overview of the Population and Housing Forecast component
November 2016

Social Isolation: Experiential Narratives of African Refugee Women in the Fargo-Moorhead Community
September 2016

Sean Brotherson: Father Involvement and the Future of Children and Families
July 2016

Carol Cwiak: Bakken Oil: What Have We Learned and What Will We Do Differently Next Time
June 2016

Jessica Creuzer: The Changing Face of Western North Dakota: What are the Effects of Increased Travel from Energy Development
April 2016

ND Compass: City Profiles
February 2016

ND Department of Health: Making Change Happen
January 2016

Jennifer Weber: A Bold New Direction for the North Dakota University System - The NDUS Edge Dashboards
December 2015

Wendy Troop-Gordon: What Has Science Taught Us About Bullying?
November 2015

ND Compass: A Look at the Youngest North Dakotans
October 2015

Kendra Erickson-Dockter: Growing Older in North Dakota
September 2015

Michael Ziesch: Data You Can Trust: The Labor Market Information Center
August 2015

Malini Srivastava and Troy Raisanen: efargo: City Scale Sustainability
July 2015

Kevin Iverson: The State Repository of Census Information- The North Dakota Census
June 2015

Wonwoo Byun: Reducing Sedentary Behavior is a Key for Obesity Prevention in Children
May 2015

Kathryn Gordon: The Science of Suicide Prevention
April 2015

ND Compass: Tell a Story with Data! The Importance of Crade-to-Career Success
March 2015

Abby Gold: Community Food Systems: Food Charters and More
February 2015

Heather Fuller-Iglesias: The Importance of Recognizing the Role of Social Support in Human Development Across the Lifespan
January 2015

Michael Carbone: Using Data to End Homelessness
December 2014

Randal Coon: Tribal Colleges Contribute to the State's Economy
November 2014

Deb White: Women's Representation in Elected Office
October 2014

Randal Coon: Pull Factors Measure Retail Trade Performance
September 2014

Karen Olson: North Dakota ranks Well Nationally with Regard to Overall Child Well-Being; However, Substantial Opportunities for Improvement Exist
August 2014

Julie Garden-Robinson: Guard Against Grilling Gaffes: Healthy Grilling and Food Safety Tips
July 2014

Michael Noone: Extreme Weather Patterns- North Dakota Has It All
June 2014

Kathleen Tweeten: Why All Community Development Decisions Should Use the Community Capitals Framework
May 2014

Clayton Hilmert: Stress effects on pregnancy: The impact of the 2009 Red River flood on birth weight
April 2014

Karen Ehrens: Food Deserts and how they impact North Dakota
March 2014

Gretchen Dobervich and Kendra Erickson-Dockter: New Geographic Profiles: How they can work for you
February 2014

Compass Staff: "New Compass Team Brings Changes in 2014"
January 2014

Donna Grandbois: "Fargo-Moorhead American Indian Community-Sponsored Health Needs Assessment"
November 2013

Karen Olson: "North Dakota KIDS COUNT - why it counts for you
October 2013

Nancy Hodur: "Western North Dakota School Administrators Face Challenges"
August 2013

Megan Chmielewski: "Annual population estimates tell interesting stories about North Dakota's growth patterns"
July 2013

Ramona Danielson: "Learn how to make the ND Compass website work for you"
May 2013

Karen Olson: "About the American Community Survey (ACS)"
February 2013

North Dakota Compass

Center for Social Research
North Dakota State University

Compass created by:
Wilder Research

© 2022. All rights reserved.