For discussion

May 2017

Do you know the Return on Investment on your charitable giving?

Kristi Huber is the President of United Way of Cass-Clay in Fargo, ND. She is passionate about connecting people to create the biggest measurable impact for the community. Kristi has lived in the Fargo-Moorhead community since 2002 and is deeply committed to working with business and nonprofit leaders and individuals to meet the changing needs of individuals and families in the community. United Way of Cass-Clay connects people to people, needs to resources, and experts to advocates to improve lives throughout Cass County, North Dakota, and Clay County, Minnesota. In 2017, United Way of Cass-Clay will invest $5.6 million toward achieving four Bold Community Goals. 

Viewing Your Donation as an Investment

When you invest your hard-earned money with a financial advisor, you expect a return. Why should philanthropy be any different?

The definition of investment is to buy something with the expectation that it will increase in value. When an individual makes a gift to United Way, they are not givers or donors, but investors. It is our job to invest their dollars into strategies that can produce results. The donors’ expectation is that there will be an increase in value for the community.

As a donor, you want to invest in a non-profit that will make a significant impact on the individuals being served and the community as a whole, while also giving you a sense of personal satisfaction. If you think of this in terms of a financial investment, say a retirement account, would you make an investment without expecting to see a return? No. You expect your investments to grow and to have access to those results. United Way feels you should also expect that from any donation you make! This is why we put such a large focus on outcomes and measurements of our investments made with donors’ dollars.

What is United Way’s strategy to invest dollars in the community?

United Way serves the community by leveraging our investments, resources, volunteers, and corporate partnerships to deliver transformative, measurable results.

In the past decade, United Way has undergone a dramatic shift in how we work to address needs in our community. We have moved away from being a historic community chest with a broad charitable mission, into a community convener that mobilizes our partners, including businesses, community leaders, public officials, residents and non-profit organizations. We use data to drive our decisions when it comes to investing in solutions that will truly “move the needle” on big community issues like hunger, homelessness, and poverty. Data and tools like ND Compass help us assess community needs and drive our investments.

But, what does United Way’s work mean for our donors, and our greater community?

United Way of Cass-Clay’s investment strategy is centered on four BOLD Community Goals that impact each and every one of us in this community.

 

With these ambitious community goals, how does United Way invest dollars from the community?

Each year, we evaluate programs’ client outcomes, financial stability and the overall impact on the community through a three-tier review process that incorporates volunteers at each stage in the process. Volunteers and data help to ensure dollars entrusted to United Way are leveraged to their maximum capacity.

How does United Way utilize data to make investments?

How do you measure success? And how often? In today’s ever-changing world, data is everything. It drives our business decisions and gives organizations the affirmation that their work is making a difference and having a return. How often does your financial advisor report back to you with the returns and results of your investments? Quarterly? Annually?

What many community members may not know is that United Way Community Partners report at least twice per year on the results of their work.

When United Way Community Partners receive investments from United Way, we include clear expectations regarding data and measurement for success. The United Way agrees and works hard to partner with leaders from each agency and program to determine these measurements for success. We also host a Logic Model and Successful Outcomes Measurement Course presented by Dr. Shawn Ginther, M.S.W., Ph.D., a local expert from Minnesota State University Moorhead. In return, our partners agree to report back to the United Way on these measurements and our Community Impact team is responsible for analyzing these reports to ensure compliance, effectiveness of our investments, and logically combine data (where we can) to show aggregate results of the work being done in our community. Some partner organizations may measure the amount of time their clients remain in stable housing, while other organizations may measure the developmental growth of children in areas such as cognitive language development.

This is what makes the United Way different! When you make an investment with the United Way you will see a return in value added to our community. Whether that is seen through saving the community thousands of dollars in reduced social service costs by housing the hardest to house, ensuring children are ready for Kindergarten, which sets them up for long term success, or helping individuals to stay in their homes longer avoiding the high annual expenses in assisted living. We want to show our donors the results and the work being done throughout the entire Cass and Clay community, because donors deserve to see the difference their investments are making!

Child Care Scholarships: An Example of How Data Drives Investments

Some may say that success is hard to measure, but when it comes to our BOLD GOALS of preparing kids to succeed and lifting people out of poverty, we know that success comes in the form of a child’s ability to recognizing letters and shapes, being developmentally on track for Kindergarten, and reading proficiency by third grade. All of these measures of success are related to one community issue: child care.

Data has proven that 90% of a child’s brain is developed by age five. Local community data also suggests that lower income families have difficulty affording the cost of high quality care. Knowing the importance of all children having access to high quality early childhood education, in 2013, United Way created an opportunity to invest in scholarships for low income families to access care at high quality child care centers.

In 2017, United Way has committed to investing half a million dollars in high quality child care scholarships for local families in need. Scholarships are invested based on capacity and number of low income families served.

Who is eligible for United Way Child Care Scholarships?

• Parents struggling to pay for child care costs
• Families living at or below the poverty level or have a financial need
• Families who qualify for child care assistance, but need more assistance for their child(ren) to enroll in high quality child care

Last year, 286 low income children and families were able to access high quality child care thanks to child care scholarships made possible by United Way investors.

What is the return?

Children are prepared to succeed in school and are prepared to succeed as future members of our workforce
Parents are able to secure and maintain a job to support their family
Employers and businesses are able to attract and retain a talented and reliable workforce

When the right investment is made in the right strategy, there is a return on investment that impacts all of us – that is United Way’s goal.

In addition to the number of children served, we are also utilizing data to measure the developmental growth of children receiving the scholarships.

The Relationship Between High Quality Child Care and a Child’s Growth and Development

Teachers and staff at the child care centers measure the progress of the children who are receiving the child care scholarships compared to all children enrolled in child care three times per year. The measurements are based off of the GOLD Teaching Strategies and measure following key indicators of a child’s growth and development in these areas:

• Social emotional
• Physical
• Language
• Cognitive
• Literacy
• Mathematics

The data collected by these dedicated teachers and staff indicates that the children receiving the child care scholarships have consistently exceeded developmental growth expectations from fall to spring.

 

Having this data has allowed United Way to not only report back to our donors and investors about the impact their dollars have on local kids, but the data has helped us demonstrate the success of this strategy and expand our ability to offer more child care scholarships to more children.

In addition to the child care scholarship data, here are two additional examples of how United Way utilizes data to describe the return on investment when people give:

Would you like to see more data and results? For more information about Community Needs and investment results, we encourage you to view our Report to the Community here on our website.

If you have questions or would like to discuss United Way’s investment strategy, please reach out to our team at unitedway@unitedwaycassclay.org or learn more at www.unitedwaycassclay.org.

More discussion

Jesseca White: Disrupting the Revolving Door: A look at alternative justice in Fargo
January 2017

Leola Daul: Heart-n-Soul Community Cafe: A Place Where All Are Welcome to Enjoy a Local, Healthy, and Delicious Meal no Matter their Ability to Pay
October 2016

Cass Clay Food Systems Advisory Commission: A Multijurisdictional Food Policy Council
August 2016

5 Ways to Join the Compass Community
May 2016

Inform, Improve, Inspire: North Dakota's First Ever Demographics Conference
March 2016

Donene Feist: Children and Youth with Special Health Care Needs in North Dakota
January 2016

ND Head Start: Vibrant Economy Leads to Workforce Shortages - Head Start Programs Statewide Are Feeling the Impact
December 2015

Lynette Schaff: Bullying- Just a Schoolyard Problem? Think Again!
November 2015

Jim Deal: Changes to Come
October 2015

Janis Cheney: AARP- Discover Your Possibilities
September 2015

John Trombley: Competition is Tough; Why Make it Tougher?
August 2015

Nick Ybarra: Keeping the Trail
July 2015

Megan Laudenschlager: Engaging Millennials
June 2015

Kim Bushaw: Brain Development
May 2015

2015 Legislative District Profiles
April 2015

ND Compass Points
March 2015

Heidi Demars: Growing a Food Cooperative from the Ground Up
February 2015

Helen Danielson: National Mentoring Month
January 2015

Sharz Miar: Giving the Gift of Hope for the Holidays
December 2014

Cheryl Ann Kary (Hunkuotawin): Talking Indian: A L/N/Dakota Model of Oratory
November 2014

North Dakota Legislative District Profiles
October 2014

Edwin Erickson Jr.: Soybeans- Growing an Important Commodity for North Dakota
September 2014

Jennifer Braun: A Look at Early Childhood Education in Western North Dakota
August 2014

Jordyn Wallenborn: Ticks Bite: Protect Yourself Against Lyme Disease
July 2014

Lorraine Shepherd-Davis: Filling a Need in the Community
June 2014

Howard Barlow: Helping Build a Better Community
May 2014

Denise Hellekson: Using Mindfulness to Calm Your Busy Mind
April 2014

Melissa Sobolik: End hunger through community partnerships
March 2014

Jacob Sowers: Places and their story: More than just a spot on the map?
February 2014

Neil Scharpe: "Protecting North Dakota's Quality of Life"
January 2014

Donald Warne: "American Indian Health Disparities in North Dakota"
November 2013

Kay Schwarzwalter: "Community building through community gardens"
October 2013

Jasper Schneider: "Rural Development in North Dakota"
August 2013

Dean Bangsund: "Economic contribution of the petroleum industry in North Dakota"
July 2013

Jane Strommen: "Addressing the education and support needs of older North Dakotans and their family members"
June 2013

Randi Roth: "In Support of North Dakota Communities"
March 2013

Richard Rathge: "Vision of North Dakota Compass"
February 2013

Paul Mattessich: "What's the real poverty rate?"
January 2013

North Dakota Compass

North Dakota Compass
www.ndcompass.org

Compass created by:
Wilder Research

© 2017. All rights reserved.